After a change of clothes and about 5 gallons of water, it was time for the grand finale. Dinner at Antica Posta. This was the sight of the Northeast tasting and while the appetizers served during it more or less fit the bill, I was assured that proper dinner service was the business. It was no lie.
Checked the GTI again and the valet seemed rather excited to see us again. I'm fairly certain it wasn't my good looks and he never made a glance at the financial advisor. Get inside and we're led downstairs to what is an empty dining room. Empty except the entire length of the bar is lined with the remnants from the tasting. About 35 feet of wine. And this isn't counting the whites that are on ice behind the bar. I love this job. Wanting to start easy I inquired as to whether or not there were any Selbach-Oster wines left over. But, of course! And guess what, he's on his way to dinner, here! Whatta you know?
My rep and myself step outside for some fresh air through a filter and next thing you know Johannes is here. We go inside and sit down for dinner, Johannes directly across, the F.A. to my left, and my twin separated at birth to my right. For those of you in the Atlanta area, you probably already know this guy. If not, consider yourself warned. John Passman is a very bad man. His shop is Atlantic Wine on Roswell Road and between he and I, we're going to change the world. Look out!
The waitrons start coming around, with the water and the like, wanting to know what we will be having for dinner. Antica Posta, as the name might imply, is an Italian restaurant. As I said before, I wasn't overly impressed with the grub at the tasting. Looking over the menu, it became pretty obvious that they weren't re-inventing the wheel. But with Italian cuisine, is it really necessary? Not in my opinion, just keep it simple, use good ingredients, and keep your ego (and sauce) in check. They nailed it! First course, pan seared scallops over a purée of chick peas. Basic and balanced. Spot on.
During all this, Johannes, the F.A. and myself are discussing various things: The F.A.'s heritage, his extensive traveling while maintaining an estate in Germany, the differences between American football and the sport the rest of the world plays (he prefers the latter, as do I). I first ask him what wines he drinks other than his own. It one of those things that I am infinitely curious about. It's rare that I get to have dinner with a winemaker, usually it's with the sales reps. Invariably they order wines that they sell to the restaurants. In their own financial interest this makes sense, but it is predictable - not very exciting. Messer Selbach prefers reds, Italian and southern Rhône, as well as dry riesling. Not necessarily his own, and he does not make many dry.
This is another curiosity. At a previous tasting, entirely German, the F.A. and I were going through the line-up. The self-serve room was arranged from left to right, dry to sweet. I'm not sure the motivation for making dry riesling in Germany, (Alsace has perfected it, so it must be a catering to the International palate. Damnit!!) but we got through them and went into the producers' room. Here, there were five wineries with either the winemaker or some relative giving a more in-depth explanation of the wines. After the second producer, the F.A. announced that she did not care for the dry rieslings at all. I concurred. We went to the third producer (von Buhl) and as he going on about the dry riesling he was pouring, I asked him what he thought about it,
personally. He seemed taken aback a bit and then responded:
"When I am in Germany, all I want is dry. As soon as I come here (the states or the south), all I want is sweet. I guess I never really noticed that before."
And here is my bigger point. The wines may be sweeter than you expect or sweeter than you are accustomed to, but in the absence of the sweetness (perceived or real) the wines seem unbalanced.
Too much acidity. You notice it more when it's not there. Johannes agreed.
Back to Antica Posta. Second course arrives. Gnocchi with a tomato sauce. As stated earlier, I am a purist. If you have the balls to put pierogie on your menu, it better come damned close to my grandmother's. Same goes for a Caesar. I want anchovies not some creamy garlic crap out of a plastic jar. Enter the gnocchi. Perfect. Nice and light. Not sure what they did with the sauce but it did not come across nearly as acidic as I had anticipated.
The conversation changes to corks. All of Johannes' wines, both estate and brokered, carry wood corks (except for a special 'entry level' bottling made exclusively for Northeast). I asked him what the corkage rate was for his wines. He admitted that there was a time when they were relatively high, but that those times were gone. What gives? What's the magic bullet?
"We got very aggressive with our cork suppliers. We only buy from two now and we pay more for them but now the corkage rate is nominal at best."
This is why you don't get brain surgery at the bar, unless you deserve it. By "nominal" he means nowhere near the 15% that Parker threw out in Food & Wine or the other reports of 25% cork taint. Straight from the horse's mouth. And a German riesling producer. Riesling shows cork taint more than any other varietal. Hah!! You get what you pay for.
We then got into reductive fermentation and all that it entails, and if you want to talk about it, drop me a line. Long story short:
do as little to the wine as possible. Words to live by.
I would love to tell you about some of the wines that we were drinking, but alas, by this point in the day, I was done. It was like this: your glass is empty, somebody goes to the bar and grabs a bottle, your glass is no longer empty. I do remember the last wine I had. Crozes-Hermitage. Unreal!! If you want to know the producer, come by the shop in a couple weeks.
It was time for the last question: Who is your peer? What other producer do you truly respect? The answer: J.J. Prum. Not exactly who I expected, but not all that surprising either. Vineyard specific, resect for the terroir, respect for the grapes, and truly German. Right on.
The rest of the evening turned into a blur. We went upstairs and proceeded to get out of Dodge. Handing the valet the ticket, he seemed awfully excited yet again. He took off down the ramp like a bastard and had the car back up in a second. As we were getting in, a man in line behind us said "what the hell is that?". His friend said "It's a Volkswagen." "Bullshit! That's the best damned VW I've ever seen". I thanked him and the F.A. got us to bed. He was driving a Lexus.
I drank cheap ass American beer for two days.